Ashlee Gabrysch

Chicago aldermen voted 45-5 on Nov. 18 to authorize an independent review of Mayor Brandon Johnson’s handling of city finances, after the resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, the third CFO departure from Johnson’s administration in lss than a year.

The same day, the City Council passed an ordinance directing the administration to restart ShotSpotter within 30 days. It also unanimously passed a resolution instructing the State of Illinois to advance a constitutional amendment for a statewide tax on people with annual incomes of $1 million.

The finance review

Ald. Marty Quinn (13th) and 11 other aldermen, including Finance Committee Chair Pat Dowell (3rd), led the push for the review.

“What passed today was that the council gave the authority to the Chairwoman of the Finance Committee, Pat Dowell, to begin a financial review of the mayor’s office, the chief financial officer, the acting corporation council and any other applicable staff,” Quinn said. “And this is all based on the falling out of our most recent Chief Financial officer, Ashlee Gabrysch.”

Ald. Marty Quinn

The Finance Committee plans to choose an outside investigator and decide what the review will cover.

“This will probably be someone with a former federal prosecutor pedigree to begin doing that review. Because in the balance here is the city’s finances and that could never be compromised,” Quinn said.

Quinn said Gabrysch’s statement that her integrity was being compromised is the reason for the review and for the urgency.

“I think the important thing is that there’s an expectation, because of the ordinance, that there’s full cooperation and that is in all involved parties,” he said. “Every day we learn something new about what has transpired with the former Chief Financial Officer, Ashlee Gabrysch.”

Quinn said the turmoil is directly affecting the city’s credit rating and the council owes it to taxpayers to get control of the issue.

The budget dispute

In his budget address, Johnson said the city’s $17.6 billion budget is 76% structurally balanced. Gabrysch put the figure at 56%. She resigned three months after starting as the CFO.

A structurally balanced budget is one where a city’s recurring revenues cover its recurring expenses over multiple years without one-time fixes, according to the Government Finance Officers Association.

Quinn said the 76% figure made him suspicious because the budget relies on one-time revenues for years to come.

“I thought that was extremely high considering how our current mayor loves to spend money and using any sources possible to spend that money,” he said. “And, so, I did question the Chief Financial Officer about that and my suspicions were confirmed when she said on the record that the structural balance of the city’s budget is more like 56%.”

“Chicago has a history of making things look a lot better than they are. … We come out with these billion-dollar deficits, and somehow, we make them disappear. Residents don’t take it seriously because it really just seems kind of performative rather than actual budgetary strife,” Gabrysch told the Chicago Sun-Times.

She said the steps taken to close the city’s $882 million shortfall are not structural solutions.

Those steps include $480 million the city is set to borrow to cover police misconduct settlements.

“I am not one that is easily bullied. I was certainly told what I could and could not say,” Gabrysch said, according to the Sun-Times. She added that when she testified before the City Council, she defied the administration, saying things she was ordered not to say.

“All that is really problematic,” Quinn said. “There can’t be politics with the city’s finances and how we’re communicating with the outside world on the state of the city’s finances.

“What’s at stake here is the interest rate we pay on our debt,” he said. “It’s a matter of fact that 40% of our operating expenses are pension funds or pension obligations and our debt.”

Quinn said residents should pay attention because the city’s “paycheck” comes from their property taxes and misrepresented numbers push interest rates higher.

‘No trust’

Ald. Raymond Lopez (15th) said the council is showing leadership by trying to find out what is happening with the city’s finances.

“We’ve always assumed we’re not being lied to and now, in light of everything that our former CFO Ashlee Gabrysch said, we have questions, especially when she herself has said that she was resigning rather than causing harm to her reputation or her fiduciary responsibilities,” Lopez said. “That’s an astounding statement for someone who’s responsible for managing our finances.”

Ald. Ray Lopez.

He said he expects the review to focus on debt, because the administration has relied heavily on new borrowing for its projects.

The ordinance requires the review to report directly to Finance Committee Chair Dowell and to be independent of the mayor, the Department of Finance and the comptroller.

“I will say there is no trust between the City Council and the Johnson administration,” Lopez said.

He said aldermen wanted a review free of interference from Johnson’s team, focused on one question: Whether the city is being truthful with rating agencies and investors about its debt and finances.

“Even now, as we’re moving forward, questions of independence are arising again as we are learning that the law department counsel, that is supposed to be in assistance to the committee, is not going to maintain attorney-client privilege between the committee and themselves, but will open the lines for the administration to keep tabs on what’s happening through the Law Dept. counsel’s office,” Lopez said.

The ordinance requires city department heads, officials and employees to cooperate with the investigators. Any who do not “shall be subject to employment sanctions, including suspension or discharge,” the ordinance says.

“It’s unfortunate, but this is where we find ourselves, that we literally have to threaten with termination our own department heads and managers into cooperating because Brandon Johnson has created a culture that views City Council as just being an archaic rubber stamp for approving budgets and ordinances,” Lopez said.

“It’s going to put us on a path, I believe, of a showdown, because I’m certain there will be some that will comply and there will be some that will not,” he said.

Lopez said the review will affect the year-end budget deadline. “I don’t know how we move forward with a budget, not knowing where we are on our finances,” he said.

Treating lines of credit as revenue, Lopez said, is “like saying because you won the lottery, that means you got a raise this year.”

Ald. Silvana Tabares (23rd), who voted for the review, said the departure was “troubling because it’s the third CFO to depart the administration in a year.” She said the review will involve the mayor, his chief of staff and senior staff.

“This review of this ordinance is really going to examine the internal communication, like emails, text messages, and to determine who knew what, when they knew it, and whether anyone was directed to misrepresent the city’s finances,” Tabares said.

ShotSpotter

The ShotSpotter ordinance passed 47-7. It directs the administration and Chief Procurement Officer Sharla Roberts to restart the gunshot detection system within 30 days. On a nonbinding Nov. 3 ballot question, 70% of voters favored restarting it.

“And residents on the Southwest Side, over 80% want ShotSpotter. So, a good day for the Southwest Side,” Quinn said.

“It should have been unanimous,” Tabares said. “And shame on those who still don’t want this tool in our city after more than 70% of residents said they want this.”

She said the ordinance ” … directs the Department of Procurement to finish the competitive bidding process the city started and award it to the lowest qualified bidder.” She accused the administration of stalling the contract, including with a pilot program Roberts later canceled.

“The point of the gunshot detection is about getting police and EMTs to a shooting victim faster, especially when no one is calling 911,” Tabares said.

Ald. Silvana Tabares

Lopez said he doubts the mayor will follow through, arguing Johnson would lose his progressive base in an election year if he restored the technology.

He noted a separate Nov. 18 special meeting convened to consider an audit by the Executive Director of the Public Safety Administration to determine license plate reader compliance with the TRUST Act. 

Asked about privacy concerns, Lopez said those worries come mostly from white liberals who have not lived in wards like his. He pointed to a road-rage killing at 47th and Western.

“You know what helped us identify her killer? License plate readers,” he said.

Millionaire’s tax

Tabares said she supports the millionaire’s tax resolution because residents want it.

“I think what I took from the millionaire’s tax and the vote is that people voted for it because they want property tax relief, and affordability is a big issue,” she said. “It’s my hope that they do something to place it on the 2028 ballot.”

Both chambers of the General Assembly would need a three-fifths majority to put it on the ballot, she said.

Lopez separated the tax from Johnson’s proposed head tax. “If you’re successful and you are making millions of dollars, that is different than saying a business that is struggling should have to pay more,” he said.

If Springfield does not act, Lopez said, it should rework the Local Government Distributive Fund, which shares state income tax revenue with cities and counties based on population. In February 2026, Gov. JB Pritzker sought to cut that share from 6.7% to 6.28% in fiscal 2027, reducing Chicago’s funding by $12.7 million, according to Capitol News Illinois.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *