Supreme Court 3rd District: Burke, O’Brien vie for open seat
By PETER HANCOCK
Capitol News Illinois
phancock@capitolnewsillinois.com
SPRINGFIELD – The race for the 3rd District Illinois Supreme Court seat features two experienced jurists in a contest that could determine partisan control of the court for the next several years.
Incumbent Justice Michael J. Burke, a Republican who was appointed to the court in 2020 to fill a vacancy created by the retirement of former Justice Robert Thomas, is seeking a full 10-year term. He faces Democrat Mary Kay O’Brien, a justice on the 3rd District Court of Appeals, who has spent nearly 19 years on the bench.
Burke has served on the bench for 30 years. A former assistant state’s attorney in DuPage County, he was appointed to the circuit court there in 2001 after serving as an associate judge since 1992. He won election to that seat in 2002 and retention in 2008. In July 2008, he was assigned to the appellate court. In 2014, he was elected to that court and remained there until his elevation to the Supreme Court.
“I think the most important thing when it comes to picking a candidate, the person you want to sit on the highest court in the state of Illinois, it really boils down to experience, and I clearly have the experience over that of my opponent,” Burke said during a recent podcast interview. “I’ve been a judge, I’m not a politician. I’ve never been a politician.”
O’Brien served in the General Assembly from 1996 to 2003 before becoming a judge. She was elected to the 3rd District appellate court in 2004 and won retention in 2014. In addition to serving as a judge on the court, she also handles several administrative duties.
She is the presiding judge in the appellate district and serves on the Illinois Supreme Court Legislative Committee, is an alternate to the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission and serves on the disciplinary arm of the Judicial Inquiry Board.
“I have a unique perspective from the fact that I practiced small-town law and I was also a legislator,” she said in a separate interview. “So I had clients, I had a small business, and I also had the opportunity to come into contact with almost every area of the law.”
Each candidate participated in a wide-ranging podcast interview with Capitol News Illinois. You can find them here and by searching Capitol News Illinois on most podcast apps.
Partisan Control
Illinois’ seven Supreme Court justices are selected from five geographic districts in partisan races. Three are elected from the 1st District, which is Cook County, and one each is elected from the other four.
Last year, Illinois lawmakers drew new district maps for the appellate courts for the first time in more than 50 years. As a result, Burke, who was originally appointed to fill a vacancy in the 2nd District, now finds himself running for a full 10-year term in the newly redrawn 3rd District, which includes DuPage, Will, Kankakee, Iroquois, Grundy, LaSalle and Bureau counties.
Democrats currently hold four of the seven Supreme Court seats, including all three from Cook County. The last person elected from the 3rd District was former Justice Thomas Kilbride, a Democrat who lost his bid for retention in the 2020 election – the first Illinois Supreme Court justice to do so.
If Burke wins his race and Republicans also claim the newly redrawn 2nd District, the court’s majority would flip to the GOP.
But Burke and O’Brien each downplayed the role partisanship plays on the court.
“I like to say that our robes aren’t red and they’re not blue, they’re black,” Burke said.
He said each judge brings their own perspective.
“I mean, if there’s someone who comes in, I guess, with a Republican conservative type perspective (they) may look at something a little differently than someone who comes in with maybe more of a liberal perspective. I guess that’s something that’s to be considered,” he said. “But generally, we should really be deciding these cases based upon the facts and the law.”
Burke noted that Kilbride was targeted in the 2020 election in part because he was part of the four-vote Democratic majority that blocked a constitutional amendment from appearing on the 2016 ballot. The amendment would have put the job of legislative redistricting in the hands of a nonpartisan commission rather than the General Assembly if it was approved by voters.
Burke said that ruling, which preceded his time on the court, caused some to criticize the court for being partisan. But he said most decisions since he’s joined the court have not been decided on strictly partisan lines.
O’Brien also said partisanship should not matter in judicial decisions.
“I think because of the role of the judicial branch, it really doesn’t matter who is in power,” O’Brien said. “And it’s not so much whether we like the law, because that doesn’t matter. It’s whether or not it’s constitutional, whether it has the right framework. Those are the important things.”
Abortion
Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed its longstanding decision in Roe v. Wade, which legalized abortion nationwide, effectively sending the question of abortion regulation back to the states.
Even before that decision, however, advocacy groups concerned about the court’s increasingly conservative rulings, including the Center for Reproductive Rights, had begun challenging state regulations in state courts, hoping to get favorable rulings from those courts declaring that abortion rights were protected under state constitutions.
That hasn’t happened in Illinois, in part because the General Assembly in 2019 passed the Reproductive Health Act which, among other things, declares abortion access a “fundamental right” under Illinois law. But Democrats are concerned that if Republicans win a majority on the state’s high court, it could open the door to legal challenges.
Specifically, O’Brien’s campaign recently released a TV ad alleging Burke has been endorsed by groups that support banning all abortions. And the independent group called All for Justice has run an ad alleging both Burke and 2nd District GOP candidate Mark Curran support banning abortions, even in cases of rape and incest.
Burke strongly denied that he has ever made any statement or given any indication of how he might rule on the issue of abortion, and on Monday a law firm representing his campaign issued a letter to stations demanding that they stop airing the ad. He also said the ads are an indicator of how politicized judicial races have become.
O’Brien also was reluctant to discuss how she would rule on any issue. Her campaign website indicates she has been endorsed by groups that support abortion rights, including Personal PAC, Equality Illinois and Illinois NOW.
O’Brien and Burke both said they routinely tell people and organizations who endorse them that the endorsement will carry no weight when they decide a case.
Madigan ties
O’Brien has also been the target of political attacks during the campaign. Republicans have criticized her for having close ties to former House Speaker Michael Madigan while she served in the General Assembly and for overturning convictions of people who’d been found guilty of violent crimes.
O’Brien, however, denied being part of the so-called “Madigan machine,” saying that during her time in the General Assembly, she received very little help from the Democratic Party.
“I was a Democrat that was elected without Mike Madigan’s help because the district was overwhelmingly Republican, 65 percent,” she said. “So I didn’t get help from the party in 1996 because they just didn’t feel that it could be won. And the voters returned me four times to the same seat that didn’t change – the demographics of the district still haven’t changed. It’s still my hometown.”
As for overturning convictions of violent criminals, O’Brien said that is sometimes part of the job of being an appellate judge when the facts of the case necessitate it.
“Any time a judge is worried about a decision having a political impact, then maybe they’re in the wrong profession,” she said. “I have always believed … when people talk about technicalities, I remind people, the Constitution is not a technicality. Our statutes and this constitution of the state and of the United States guarantee certain processes and freedoms and requirements in the criminal and civil context, and without the judiciary upholding those requirements, we really aren’t doing our job.”
Both Burke and O’Brien discussed several other issues, from administrative processes of the court to what decisions they have found challenging, during their interviews with Capitol News Illinois which can be found here.
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service covering state government that is distributed to more than 400 newspapers statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.
Local News
Palos Park to allow Cog Hill to apply for video gaming
Spread the loveBy Jeff Vorva At 8:25 p.m. Monday night the long-awaited decision was made on video gaming in Palos Park. After months of conversation and listening to businesses and the public, the village council voted 3-1 to allow the only Class G liquor license business in town – Cog Hill Golf and Country Club…
Pritzker, Ezike address plan to lift mask mandate
Spread the loveSchool mandates would remain in place for ‘coming weeks,’ pending court decision By Jerry Nowicki Capitol News Illinois and Tim Hadac If COVID-19 hospitalizations continue to decline for the rest of the month, Gov. JB Pritzker plans to lift his executive order that mandates face coverings indoors by Feb. 28. The plan does…
Eagle healed, released to mate
Spread the loveRescuers thrilled with victory By Kelly White Wildlife advocates last week released an eagle in the forest preserves several blocks northwest of Garfield Ridge. The eagle was the subject of a story last month in the Clear-Ridge Reporter & NewsHound. The release marked the end of a six-week rehabilitation stint that started when…
Ease off vax regs, aldermen ask
Spread the loveQuinn, Burke, Tabares say regs ‘cripple’ businesses By Tim Hadac With numbers of newly diagnosed COVID-19 cases falling across the city, the three aldermen serving Clearing and Garfield Ridge are among 11 City Council members who last week called on Chicago Department of Public Health Allison Arwady, M.D. to rescind a pandemic regulation…
Del Galdo named Super Lawyer for 12th straight year
Spread the loveLauded by suburban mayors for skills From staff reports A national legal magazine is out with its 2022 list of best Illinois lawyers and tapped eight Chicago-area attorneys as the state’s “super” local government lawyers–including Berwyn-based attorney Michael Del Galdo, a recognition that drew praise from several suburban Cook County mayors. “Super Lawyers” magazine,…
They had my back when I was stuck
Spread the loveBy Joan Hadac Your correspondent in Clearing and Garfield Ridge (708) 496-0265 • joan.hadac@gmail.com We’ve dug out from snowmagedon, and I want to personally thank the three people on 61st Street who came to my rescue when I got stuck in the snow. I was nervous and I was making all the mistakes a…
Summit wants to hear from residents
Spread the loveThe Village of Summit is looking to get input from its residents on a variety of issues. Summit, in partnership with Metropolitan Mayors Caucus, the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning, and the Illinois Housing Development Authority, is undertaking a Community Needs Assessment survey as a part of the Homes for a Changing Region…
Lyons Township to co-sponsor St. Patrick’s Day Parade in Countryside
Spread the loveBy Steve Metsch The annual Countryside St. Patrick’s Day Parade is getting a boost from the Township of Lyons. The township board unanimously approved a $1,000 sponsorship for the city’s popular event. “We have traditionally sponsored this event,” Township Supervisor Christopher Getty said at the board’s Feb. 8 meeting. “Although we have not…
Lyons man ‘accomplished something’ with Kilimanjaro climb
Spread the loveBy Steve Metsch Stephan Alheim of Lyons learned a lot about himself while making the 19,341-foot climb to the top of Mount Kilimanjaro in Tanzania. He learned preparation is important, especially when it comes to breathing properly. He also learned to have faith in the climbing guides. And he learned to always bring…
Lyons to raise water rate as Chicago charges more
Spread the loveBy Steve Metsch With its hand forced by Chicago, the Lyons Village Board has unanimously approved an increase in the water rate. The new rates will take effect March 1. Lyons has no choice but to raise the rate since Chicago raised the rate it charges water suppliers that sell water to the…
Neighbors
Titanic memories haunt Worth Library
Spread the loveBy Kelly White This year marks the 112th anniversary of the Titanic’s fateful ship crossing. Bringing the ship back to life was the Worth Public Library on April 15 with a program called, The Haunted Titanic, with local historian Bob Trzeciak, who walked patrons through the history, the lasting impact, and why it…
Spring cleanup day in Bridgeview set for Saturday
Spread the loveBy Steve Metsch Any Bridgeview resident with clutter to clear will be busy Friday night, May 10. That’s when they will be putting all kinds of things on the parkway as the village prepares for its annual spring cleanup day set for Saturday, May 11. All items must be at the curb by…
Family of man killed in McCook struggling with his absence
Spread the loveBy Steve Metsch On what would have been his 37th birthday, the family of Morales Ricardo Lopez gathered at his grave in Evergreen Park Cemetery. Lopez, of Blue Island, was gunned down in McCook early Feb. 17, leaving behind a widow and three children. His family, other relatives and friends gathered at his…
Southwest Symphony presents ‘American Song Book’
Spread the loveFrom staff reports Southwest Symphony Orchestra will perform “The American Song Book” this weekend at Trinity College in Palos Heights. The performance will feature Grammy nominated Helen Welch under the direction of David Crane at 7:30 p.m. Saturday in Trinity Christian College’s Ozinga Auditorium. Welch will perform some of America’s best loved classics.…
Shoppers welcome back Evergreen Park Farmers Market
Spread the loveBy Joe Boyle Rain was forecast for the morning of May 2, but nothing could dampen the spirits of customers who dropped by the Evergreen Park Farmers Market. The large crowd that attended were instead greeted with mostly sunny skies. Beth Novotney, director of the Evergreen Park Office of Citizen Services that oversees…
Evergreen Park recognizes police for valor
Spread the loveBy Joe Boyle The Evergreen Park police have been cited for valor after several key arrests that occurred the past couple of months. Police Chief Michael Saunders requested commendations for the officers during the Evergreen Park Village Board meeting Monday night. Mayor Kelly Burke and the board applauded the efforts of the force.…
Hickory Hills police bid adieu and say welcome
Spread the loveBy Nuha Abdessalam The Hickory Hills Police Department bid a fond farewell to Lieutenant Glenn Tienstra and welcomed new Officer Daniel Balzhiser. On a memorable Thursday evening, April 25, city hall was filled with the warmth of community family, friends, officers, and council members, all gathered to joyfully celebrate Officer Balzhiser and respectfully…
Mother Mac unveils new lights and scoreboard
Spread the loveBy Kelly White Across the nation, women’s sports are on the rise in terms of viewership, enthusiasm, sponsorship and excitement. Mother McAuley is no stranger to the impact that women’s athletics has on the development of an individual, strengthening of a team and key skills and attributes developed along the way. South Side…
Cicadas in the park in Palos Park
Spread the loveBy Kelly White Cicadas are coming and the Village of Palos Park is ready. The village hosted its 31st annual Arbor Day Celebration on Sunday, May 5, themed, “The Wonder of Trees” at The Center in the Lodge, 12700 Southwest Highway, with featured speaker, Tricia Bethke of The Morton Arboretum who presented, “Cicadas…
Palos Heights SD 128 sees enrollment boom
Spread the loveBy Kelly White Over the past few years, Palos Heights School District 128 has experienced an explosive growth among incoming students. There has been a significant increase particularly at Indian Hill Early Learning Center, 12800 S. Austin Ave. Chippewa Elementary School, 12425 S. Austin Ave; Navajo Elementary School, 12401 S. Oak Park Ave;…