The Tylenol murders case still remains unsolved to this day. (Photo by Kelly Whit

More than 40 years after cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules terrified the Chicago region and claimed seven lives, two Chicago Tribune investigative reporters brought the story, and its modern relevance, to the Oak Lawn Public Library.

Christy Gutowski and Stacy St. Clair, co-creators of the Tribune’s acclaimed Unsealed: The Tylenol Murders series and podcast, spoke to a packed crowd August 20 at the library, 9427 Raymond Ave., about the unsolved case that reshaped consumer safety and continues to captivate the public.

Christy Gutowski and Stacy St. Clair, co-creators of the Tribune’s acclaimed Unsealed: The Tylenol Murders series and podcast, spoke to a packed crowd at the library, 9427 Raymond Ave., about the unsolved case. (Photo by Kelly White)

“We’ve found out that people really want to talk to us about this,” Stacy St. Clair said.

The program was part of OLPL’s True Crime Summer series and was organized by Adult/Young Adult Programming Librarian Kate Donley. She said the idea came from the crime’s enduring notoriety and Gutowski’s ties to the community.

“The Tylenol murders rocked Chicagoland and are a well-known crime across the U.S.,” Donley said. “I had heard that one of the experts had a connection to Oak Lawn, which I thought was very exciting. I reached out to Christy Gutowski, and she was excited to collaborate with her hometown library.”

Gutowski, who grew up in Oak Lawn, reflected on her deep personal connection to the community and to the library itself.

“My family moved to Oak Lawn when I was in the fourth grade. I attended St. Gerald’s for church and graduated Covington and Oak Lawn Community High School,” she said. “I recall spending many hours in the library studying and researching class projects. In fact, the library helped foster my love for research, reading, and journalism. The childhood friendships I formed in Oak Lawn remain my most treasured and, decades later, I remain very close to my former classmates.”

During the hourlong talk, Gutowski and St. Clair outlined the 1982 killings, their investigation into the case and the creation of Unsealed. Audience members also had the opportunity to ask questions about the case and about investigative journalism.

“This was a terrifying 24-hours that left seven people dead,” Gutwoski said.

“Local media broke the Tylenol story within 24-hours of the first death, which probably saved lives,” St. Cair added.

Donley said the program gave residents a chance to engage with nationally recognized journalists while reflecting on a crime that left a lasting mark on local history.

“True crime is one of the hottest genres in books and podcasting,” she said. “Not only did the public learn about this piece of Oak Lawn history, they had the chance to connect to true crime investigators.”

She added that the library was honored to welcome Gutowski and St. Clair.

“We were thrilled to have two Chicago Tribune journalists visiting our library who are also national experts on the Tylenol murders,” Donley said.

Though the murders remain unsolved, they led to sweeping changes in consumer safety, including the tamper-resistant packaging that is now standard.

For many in attendance, especially longtime Oak Lawn residents who remember the panic of 1982, the program offered both a history lesson and a chance to reflect on how the tragedy reshaped daily life.

The Oak Lawn Public Library held a program on the 1982 Tylenol murders on Wednesday night. (Photo by Kelly White)